I used to be on an in a single day flight from Los Angeles to New York Metropolis through the Academy Awards, so at first I didn’t see the Will Smith–Chris Rock fiasco that despatched America into a whole tizzy. However once I was lastly capable of activate my cellphone, I had 653 textual content messages.

600 and fifty-three.

By now, you’ve in all probability seen a number of movies and angles of Smith slapping Rock. Proper earlier than the comic offered the Oscar for Greatest Documentary, Rock joked offhand that he was trying ahead to seeing Smith’s spouse, Jada Pinkett Smith, in G.I. Jane 2. Rock was referring to Jada’s bald head. The issue with the joke is that Jada has been open about affected by alopecia, an autoimmune dysfunction that generally leads to important hair loss. When the cameras panned to her, her expression confirmed that she was under no circumstances happy with Rock’s barb. Moments later, Smith walked onstage and smacked Rock within the face.

Learn: Will Smith hit Chris Rock. Then he gained an Oscar.

Whereas I used to be on the aircraft, my group-text threads exploded with plenty of jokes, and plenty of surprised reactions. Most of my 653 texts, I ought to notice, got here from Black of us. A number of them, each women and men, stated they not less than understood Will Smith’s fierce response to Rock’s mockery of his spouse, even when they disagreed with how and the place Smith confirmed it.

What has developed since that unforgettable second on the Oscars is a traditional “two Americas” dialog. By that I imply: Black folks and white folks aren’t essentially speaking concerning the incident in the identical approach. That a lot was evident within the celeb response. Tiffany Haddish, a Black actor and comic who starred with Jada Smith within the blockbuster film Ladies Journey, informed Folks: “After I noticed a Black man arise for his spouse[,] that meant a lot to me.” To my eyes, Black commentators have been extra prepared to joke concerning the incident—maybe as a result of, as Will Packer, the tv and movie megaproducer who oversaw the Oscars broadcast, tweeted after the present, “Black folks have a defiant spirit of laughter on the subject of coping with ache as a result of there was a lot of it.”

In distinction, Judd Apatow, a director who’s white, tweeted that Smith “might have killed” Rock. “That’s pure uncontrolled rage and violence,” Apatow continued. “They’ve heard one million jokes about them within the final three many years. They don’t seem to be freshman [sic] on the earth of Hollywood and comedy. He misplaced his thoughts.” Apatow has since deleted this tweet.

The radio shock jock Howard Stern even went to date as to check Smith to former President Donald Trump. “That is how Trump will get away with shit,” Stern stated on his present. “Will Smith and Trump are the identical man. He determined he’s going to take issues into his personal arms.”

Whoo, boy.

I’m not saying that every one Black folks agree with Haddish or that every one white folks agree with Apatow and Stern; one ballot discovered that, throughout racial strains, most People assume Smith shouldn’t have slapped Rock. However I can’t assist however discover the disproportionate outrage that many individuals in white America—and lots of within the Hollywood elite—are displaying. In accordance with The New York Put up, unnamed trade insiders already are asking if Smith’s award needs to be rescinded. The Academy introduced it’s going to conduct its personal investigation and “will discover additional motion and penalties in accordance with our Bylaws, Requirements of Conduct and California legislation.” If the Academy chooses to not enable Smith to current an award subsequent 12 months—an honor sometimes bestowed upon Greatest Actor winners—then that’s tremendous. However taking away Smith’s Oscar could be absurd, contemplating that the producer Harvey Weinstein, who has been convicted of rape, nonetheless has his Oscar. Roman Polanski, who pleaded responsible to statutory rape, and Mel Gibson, who has an unsightly historical past of racist and anti-Semitic remarks, nonetheless have theirs too.

Some critics appear incredulous that Smith would reply the way in which he did. He and his household have been within the public eye for many years, and a bodily confrontation additionally doesn’t jibe with the gregarious picture that Smith has all the time offered. If something, Smith has needed to take care of the notion that he isn’t powerful, as a result of all through a lot of his rap profession, he was thought of the antithesis of hard-core hip-hop, which used imagery about violence, medicine, and poverty. Smith’s songs have been enjoyable, joyful, and light-hearted. To some, that meant he was delicate.

As a married couple, the Smiths have leaned into exposing their flaws. They’ve been extraordinarily open—some would say somewhat too clear—concerning the challenges they’ve confronted as a married couple. Two years in the past, Jada confirmed on her common Fb speak present, Purple Desk Speak, that she had an affair with the R&B singer August Alsina. (Throughout the present, Jada and Will Smith stated she had finished so once they have been separated.)

Jada described her affair with Alsina as an “entanglement.” On the Display screen Actors Guild Awards earlier this month, the E! community’s red-carpet interviewer, Laverne Cox, stated to the couple: “We will’t await extra Purple Desk Speak and extra entanglements.” To place it mildly, it was a particularly awkward second.

Learn: The unreality of Will Smith’s Oscar slap

The Smiths’ willingness to disclose sure facets of their private lives doesn’t imply that they need to be subjected to tasteless jokes. On the identical time, Will Smith has no proper to go round placing his arms on folks. Shortly after smacking Rock, Smith gained the Oscar for Greatest Actor for his portrayal of Richard Williams, the boisterous father of the tennis stars Venus and Serena Williams, within the film King Richard. Smith tried to deliver some levity to the scenario throughout his acceptance speech. “I appear to be the loopy father identical to they stated about Richard Williams,” he stated. “However love will make you do loopy issues.” Sadly for Smith, his first Oscar win is now sullied by his egregious conduct.

Numerous the individuals who texted me additionally apprehensive that the incident—an embarrassing second involving two distinguished Black celebrities—would additionally sully Black folks extra usually. Final evening’s Oscars have been the primary with an all-Black manufacturing group. Black persons are conditioned to imagine that we deserve respect, admiration, and recognition of our humanity based mostly solely on good conduct. However Smith’s overreaction doesn’t replicate on anybody else however him, and the suggestion that our group ought to really feel any measure of collective disgrace is totally misguided. Nor ought to we feed into the dehumanizing stereotype that Smith’s conduct is typical for Black folks.

In contrast to some folks reacting on social media, I refuse to take a look at this ordeal past face worth. The one folks I really feel unhealthy for are Jada Pinkett Smith, the Williams household, and my good friend Ahmir “Questlove” Thompson—all of whom noticed their very own achievements overshadowed on the Oscars. Thompson, the co-creator of the hip-hop band The Roots, directed Summer season of Soul, which gained the Oscar for Greatest Documentary Function—the class Rock was asserting earlier than his run-in with Smith’s hand. One way or the other, Thompson managed to miss the absurdity of the scenario whereas onstage giving his touching acceptance speech. I don’t know the way he did it. Finally, laughter is about the one emotion I can muster when fascinated with every little thing that transpired final evening.